The Inheritance (review)

Everyman-Theatre-The-Inheritance-Joel-Horwood-as-Toby-and-Andrew-MacMillan-as-LeoThis epic play by Matthew Lopez was inspired by his response to E.M. Forster’s 1910 novel Howard’s End. Lopez found parallels between his own life and Forster’s closeted existence before the partial decriminalisation of homosexuality.

With The Inheritance Lopez takes the opportunity to compare the lives and loves of gay men in contemporary New York a generation after the AIDS crisis, to those of Forster’s generation, and through his characters, raises questions about what the current generation owes to its forebears, going so far as to include E.M Forster as one of the characters, in this production performed by Duncan Driver. Forster acts as an observer and commentator but as the play progresses these roles are shared among the various actors.

For his production for Everyman Theatre, director Jarrad West has assembled an accomplished ensemble cast of twelve men and one woman. His clever stage design has the audience seated on both sides of a central raised playing area, allowing the opportunity to arrange his actors in a succession of visually arresting tableau to tantalise the eyes as the play progresses.

The Inheritance is written in two acts, each over three hours in length and designed to be experienced sequentially. However, in this case there is opportunity to attend different performances if preferred.

But despite the obvious demands the length of the play makes on both audience and cast, it says a great deal about the brilliance of the writing, the performances, and particularly West’s resourceful direction, that the time flies by as the audience becomes engrossed in the complexities of the lives of the characters, and the arguments in which they engage that allows Lopez to have them debate such conundrums as how to hold onto gay history and the appropriation of their language by the mainstream.

Everyman-Theatre-The-Cast-of-The-Inheritance-photo-by-Janelle-McMenaminAlthough the production is very much an ensemble piece, several performances remain in the mind long after the play is over. With his performance as the deeply conflicted Toby who destroys himself, and everyone around him with his search for authenticity, Joel Horwood dominates the production. His multi-faceted, deeply committed performance is both dangerous and masterful, making it impossible to tear your eyes away from him whenever he is on stage.

Andrew MacMillan, cleverly cast in the dual roles of Adam and Leo for reasons that become obvious as the play unfolds, captivates with the subtlety of his differentiation between the two characters.

Rhys Robinson as the elegant billionaire Henry Wilcox who finds himself challenged in a tense argument about white privilege, and James McMahon as Eric who finds himself ostracised by his friends for his decisions, both reveal themselves as actors of considerable depth and range.

Karen Vickery brings considerable gravitas to the only female role in the play, that of a mother, Margaret, who towards the end of the play talks of the devastation of losing her son to AIDS.

The Inheritance is a play of particular relevance to the gay community. This production includes graphic scenes depicting gay sexual activity which some might find confronting. However, for anyone with an appetite for quality theatre this production offers a memorable theatrical feast which should not be missed.


The Inheritance
ACT HUB, 14 Spinifex Street, Kingston (Canberra)
Performance: Sunday 20 October 2024
Season continues to 2 November 2024
Information and Bookings: www.acthub.com.au

Images: Joel Horwood as Toby and Andrew MacMillan as Leo in The Inheritance – photo by Janelle McMenamin | The Cast of The Inheritance – photo by Janelle McMenamin

Review: Bill Stephens OAM